Why having a public feature request board is bad

Ruben Buijs
Ruben Buijs
November 7, 2023
Why having a public feature request board is bad

Table of contents


Definition of a Public Feature Request Board

As a product manager at ProductLift, I understand the significance of a public feature request board in the product life cycle. It serves as a platform for users to submit their ideas, suggestions, and feedback, thereby contributing to the continuous improvement of the product. The transparency of this board allows for open communication and collaboration between the development team and the user community. However, it also brings about challenges and considerations that need to be carefully addressed.

Purpose of a Public Feature Request Board

As the Product Owner role in a SaaS company, the purpose of a public feature request board is to gather feedback and suggestions from users, allowing for greater transparency and collaboration. This fosters a sense of community and involvement among users, as they feel heard and valued. Additionally, it provides a platform for users to upvote and prioritize features, giving insight into the most desired enhancements. This information is invaluable for making data-driven decisions and aligning the product roadmap with user needs and expectations. Ultimately, the purpose of a public feature request board is to empower users and drive product innovation through active participation and feedback.

Benefits of a Public Feature Request Board

As a product manager using ProductLift, I have experienced the benefits of a public feature request board firsthand. It provides a direct channel for users to share their ideas and suggestions, fostering a sense of community and collaboration. Additionally, it allows for transparency in the decision-making process, giving users insight into how their feedback is being considered. This open communication fosters trust and loyalty among users, leading to increased engagement and a stronger user community. Furthermore, it enables the prioritization of feature requests based on user feedback, ensuring that the most valuable enhancements are addressed. The public feature request board also serves as a platform for gathering user feedback during the crucial testing phase, allowing for real-time insights into user experiences and preferences.

Challenges of Transparency

Risk of Revealing Sensitive Information

As the founder of ProductLift, I understand the importance of maintaining transparency while safeguarding sensitive information. Marketplace dynamics and competitive strategies are highly confidential, and the risk of revealing such information on a public feature request board is a major concern. To address this, we implement strict access controls and review processes to ensure that only non-sensitive information is shared with the public. Our commitment to transparency is unwavering, but we also recognize the need to protect our users' and our company's strategic data.

Managing User Expectations

As a product manager, it's crucial to manage user expectations effectively. This involves clear communication and setting realistic timelines for feature requests. We understand that users are eager to see their requested features implemented, but it's important to convey the complexity of the development process and the need to prioritize based on various factors. At ProductLift, we aim to provide a seamless code integration experience, and this requires careful consideration of user requests within the context of our overall product roadmap. By maintaining open communication and providing transparency, we can ensure that users have a clear understanding of the development process and the factors that influence feature prioritization.

Potential for Negative Publicity

As the Product Manager of ProductLift, I understand the potential for negative publicity that comes with a public feature request board. It's essential to address concerns related to transparency and user expectations to avoid any backlash. Task prioritization is a critical aspect that requires careful handling to prevent any negative impact on our brand reputation. By proactively managing these challenges, we can mitigate the risk of negative publicity and ensure that our product development process remains focused and efficient.

Impact on Development Process

Increased Workload for Development Team

As a product manager, the increased workload for the development team is a critical consideration when evaluating the impact of a public feature request board. The influx of feature requests from users, especially those related to custom domain functionality, can lead to a significant increase in the development team's workload. This can result in longer lead times for feature implementation, as well as potential delays in addressing other critical aspects of the product roadmap. Prioritizing and managing these requests becomes a complex task, requiring careful consideration of the trade-offs involved. It's essential to find a balance between addressing user needs and maintaining the overall efficiency of the development process.

Difficulty in Prioritizing Requests

As a product manager, the challenge of prioritizing feature requests can be daunting. With a large volume of requests coming in from various sources, it becomes increasingly difficult to decide which features should be given priority. The generate team names process involves evaluating the impact of each request on the product's roadmap and the overall user experience. Additionally, balancing the needs of different user segments and aligning requests with the company's strategic goals adds another layer of complexity to the prioritization process. As a result, the development team may face challenges in efficiently allocating resources and ensuring that the most valuable features are addressed in a timely manner.

Impact on Product Roadmap

As a product manager, the Product Roadmap is a crucial tool for planning and executing the development of new features and improvements. However, the introduction of a public feature request board can significantly impact the prioritization process. The influx of user requests may lead to increased workload for the development team, making it challenging to allocate time and resources effectively. Furthermore, the difficulty in prioritizing these requests can result in delays and uncertainty in the development process. This, in turn, may affect the alignment of the Product Roadmap with the company's strategic goals and vision. To address these challenges, it is essential to establish clear criteria and guidelines for evaluating and incorporating user requests into the Product Roadmap.

Security and Privacy Concerns

Exposure of Vulnerabilities

As a product manager, the exposure of vulnerabilities on a public feature request board can be a major concern. It opens up the possibility of sensitive information about product features and development processes being accessible to a wide audience, including potential attackers. This exposure can lead to increased security risks and potential exploitation of vulnerabilities. Furthermore, the transparency of the board may inadvertently highlight weaknesses in the product's security, which could impact customer trust and confidence in the product. It is essential to carefully consider the implications of exposing vulnerabilities and to implement robust security measures to safeguard the integrity and confidentiality of sensitive data.

Data Privacy and Compliance

As the ProductLift platform is designed to handle sensitive information about our users and their products, data privacy and compliance are of utmost importance to us. We take great care in ensuring that our platform meets the highest standards of security and privacy. Our commitment to compliance with regulations such as GDPR and CCPA is reflected in our robust security measures and privacy controls. When it comes to Release Notes, we adhere to strict guidelines to ensure that no sensitive information is inadvertently disclosed in our public Release Notes. Our dedication to maintaining the privacy and security of our users' data is unwavering, and we continuously strive to enhance our platform's security and privacy features.

Mitigating Security Risks

As the value proposition of ProductLift lies in providing a secure and reliable platform for SaaS products, mitigating security risks is of paramount importance. We employ a multi-layered approach to security, including regular security audits, encryption of sensitive data, and strict access controls. Additionally, our team is dedicated to staying updated with the latest security best practices and compliance standards to ensure the highest level of security for our users. By prioritizing security and privacy, we uphold our commitment to safeguarding the trust and confidence of our customers.

Start your free trial

Join over 300+ product managers already growing with ProductLift.

Don’t just take our word for it

Hear from some of our amazing customers who are building better products with ProductLift.
"This app will help you connect with your users and gather feedback like never before. The UI is clean and focused. The different pages and forms can be fully customized."
Product Manager
"This is a really great `Public roadmap and product idea page. It's totally customizable and you can set it up with your custom domain"
"It's a joy to use, and I've been constantly surprised (in the best way) about features and advanced options available. I feel comfortable building on this platform for the long term."
R Pillz
Product Owner